Childbirth compensation cost 'would fund full Banbury maternity service six times over'

The cost of childbirth negligence insurance is six times more than the cost of running Banbury’s full maternity service, it is claimed.

The contention, made by Keep the Horton General (KTHG) campaign group, comes as the Oxford University Hospitals Trust (OUH) says it paid nearly £18.5m to insure against maternity negligence claims.

Claims totalling nearly £30m have been paid to families since 2020, as the Banbury Guardian revealed in this report.

KTHG said the running costs for the Horton Maternity Hospital were £2.3m a year before it was made a midwife-only unit. The OUH downgraded Banbury’s consultant-led maternity unit in 2016.

The cost of insurance for maternity compensation is 'six times the cost of running the Horton maternity hospital'placeholder image
The cost of insurance for maternity compensation is 'six times the cost of running the Horton maternity hospital'

The unit had delivery rooms, two operating theatres, a special care baby unit and large ante-natal and post-natal wards. It delivered 1,500 – 1,750 babies per year before population increases over the past decade.

At the time of the downgrade, the OUH said the midwife-led unit that replaced it would deliver 720 babies a year. It is currently delivering around 130.

Figures obtained by the Banbury Guardian show the OUH paid the Clinical Negligence Scheme for Trusts (CNST) £42,163,115 last year (2025 – 26). Of that £18,429,171 related to maternity claims.

The OUH said there were 71 outstanding birth-related claims as of May 31, 2025.

Dismissed claims numbered 91 between 2020 – 2025 and 25 claims are approved and awaiting an agreed settlement.

KTHG says the numbers highlight issues the group has been campaigning on. It believes it was a serious mistake to close Oxfordshire’s second obstetric (consultant-led) maternity unit which, the group believes, has led to repeated birth trauma for mothers.

The group published a dossier of 50 cases of birth trauma suffered by women from the Banbury area two years ago and is compiling a second volume.

Charlotte Bird of KTHG said: “It is truly shocking. It is an obscene amount on money being spend on something that shouldn’t exist in the first place. The Horton’s full maternity service cost £2m – £3m a year to run. The amount of money spent on the premium for negligence claims would pay for the Horton unit six times over.

"Apart from the unreasonable access problems families have getting to Oxford, the JR was never going to be able to manage the births of so many Banbury women as well as its own.

"It is the only county in England of comparable population that only has one consultant-led unit. And the recent National Maternity & Neonatal Report condemned its facilities as outdated and ‘not fit for purpose’.

"There is no time to lose to start planning for the reinstatment of the Horton obstetric unit. It will take time and work must begin now.”

Chairman Keith Strangwood said: “Oxford should be leading the way, being a Trust with a reputation that is recognised far and wide for its excellence. The JR needs to make urgent changes to show the rest of the UK how it is done. It needs to be proactive, not reacting using damage control.

"The OUH Director of Clinical Services said after the downgrade that if the Secretary of State for Health decided obstetrics had to be returned to the Horton, the finances would be found to do so.

"Now is the time. The population increase demands it. Mothers should not be suffering trauma giving birth.”

An OUH spokesperson said: “Contributions to the Clinical Negligence Scheme for Trusts (CNST) are set nationally by NHS Resolution. They reflect the size and complexity of the services a trust provides.

"As a specialist centre for complex pregnancies and births, we care for women and families from across the region and deliver around 7,500 babies each year.

“In the most recent year, the Trust achieved full compliance with all ten safety actions in NHS Resolution's Maternity Incentive Scheme, which independently assesses maternity safety standards and reduces our contribution to the scheme as a result.

“Patient safety remains paramount to us. As an organisation we are continually looking at how we can learn and improve and we are working openly with families, our staff, and our regulators to strengthen our maternity services.

“We work with patients, families, and carers to resolve any compensation claim at the earliest opportunity.”

Figures obtained by Medical Negligence Assist through Freedom of Information found that between 2020-2025, families whose babies were born at Oxford University Hospitals Trust birth units have been paid a total of £29,010,915.

In that time 71 claims involving birth injuries were lodged against the trust, 32 of which have been settled.

The highest number of claims came in 2022/23, with a total of 18. The next highest was 2023/24 with 17 claims.

There is a wide range of injuries that can result from births, such as bone fractures (especially of the collarbone) or brachial plexus injuries, which involve damage to nerves in the neck and shoulder.

Other common types of birth injuries caused by oxygen deprivation can directly affect the brain through conditions like cerebral palsy or hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy.

Complications can arise from different factors like prolonged or difficult labour, foetal malposition, delivery trauma and maternal conditions such as diabetes or infection.

Keep the Horton General has appealed to women who have suffered birth trauma at Oxfordshire birth units to contact them in confidence at [email protected]

Baroness Amos, who led the National Maternity & Neonatal Investigation, reported severe pressure on JR staff caused by outdated facilities, chronic overcrowding and staff shortages, which led to dangerous logjams, long waits and unsafe staffing levels – see here.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1838
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice