‘Banbury is being held to ransom’: Councillor demands clarity over Cherwell Street scaffolding collapse
Cherwell Street has now been fully closed again following an inspection by Cherwell District Council which found that the collapsed scaffolding had deteriorated further.
A Banbury councillor has called for greater clarity over the future of the building site on Cherwell Street and the closure of the road, claiming the town is being “held to ransom” by the continuing traffic disruption.


Cllr Paul-Austin Sargent, who represents Grimsbury and Castle, said residents and businesses deserved more information about the work needed to make the site of last month's scaffolding collapse safe and how long the disruption could continue.
He said the closure was having a direct impact on residents he represents, particularly those relying on Middleton Road and Bridge Street to travel in and out of Grimsbury.
He said: “Grimsbury residents rely overwhelmingly on Middleton Road and Bridge Street as the principal routes into and out of the neighbourhood.
“Any significant disruption on the Cherwell Street corridor inevitably has a direct impact on the daily lives of the people I serve.”
Cllr Sargent has called on the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) to provide greater clarity about the process being followed, including the status of proposed construction method statements and the expected timescale for remedial work.
However, the HSE has confirmed that responsibility for making the site safe rests with the contractor, while its inspectors investigate the cause of the collapse and provide technical advice.
A spokesperson for the HSE said: “Our inspectors are carrying out an investigation to establish the cause of a partial building collapse on Cherwell Street and providing advice to the contractor – who is responsible for the works to make the site safe and prevent further injury.
“We remain in close contact with Cherwell District Council which is responsible for the management of the road.”
Cllr Sargent said there had been insufficient communication from the HSE about what would happen next.
He added: “Residents, businesses and town centre traders are entitled to understand what happens next. To date, there appears to have been very little public communication regarding the HSE's expectations, timescales, or contingency plans.
“Instead, there seems to be an assumption that the developer will simply deal with the aftermath. That is not good enough. The HSE are effectively holding the town to ransom.”
He also warned that continued uncertainty could affect businesses during the important Christmas trading period.
He said: “We are now entering one of the most important trading periods of the year for our town centre businesses. Retailers, hospitality venues and other local enterprises need certainty, not silence.
“They need to know whether disruption will continue for days, weeks or months so they can plan accordingly.”


Cherwell District Council closed the road to traffic and pedestrians again on Tuesday (November 17) following an inspection which found the scaffolding had deteriorated further, and presented a “significant risk of further structural failure”.
Oxfordshire County Council's cabinet member for transport, Cllr Gareth Epps, welcomed Cherwell District Council's latest decision to close the road following the inspection.
He said: “I had written to the HSE to kickstart action. It's only right that Cherwell has investigated, acted promptly; and councils will now take action to restore public safety (first and foremost) and the traffic network in this busy location.”
Cllr Sargent concluded that residents deserved clear information and accountable decision-making, adding that he would continue to press for answers on behalf of those affected across Banbury.
The Banbury Guardian has contacted the construction company understood to be responsible for the building site for an update regarding plans for the site.