Plans to axe scrutiny committee for Banbury’s Horton Hospital scrapped

A plan to axe a scrutiny committee for the Horton Hospital, described as “utterly disingenuous to the people of Banbury and all of Oxfordshire”, has been scrapped.

Oxfordshire County Council’s annual meeting on Tuesday, May 12, saw a heated debate on the removal of the Horton Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee (Horton HOSC).

The meeting’s agenda states the council was recommended “to decommission” the committee.

According to the plan’s proponents in the Liberal Democrat administration, the committee was poorly attended and had failed to come together all year, in part due to its constitution, which requires councillors from the different counties the Horton serves to attend.

Councillors scrapped plans to axe the Horton Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee (Horton HOSC) at Oxfordshire County Council’s annual meeting on Tuesday, May 12.placeholder image
Councillors scrapped plans to axe the Horton Joint Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee (Horton HOSC) at Oxfordshire County Council’s annual meeting on Tuesday, May 12.

The hospital has faced a number of challenges over the decades, including to its existence.

In recent years, the hospital has had maternity services downgraded and a ‘requires improvement’ judgement for the department by the Care Quality Commission.

Cllr Kieron Mallon (Conservative) said he was a long-standing member of the HOSC and stated: “I propose we do not decommission this committee. You never know when it may be needed.

“And to reset it up from scratch, we’d be doing a disservice for the people of the three counties that are involved.”

Cllr Mark Cherry (Labour) also opposed the decommission, calling it “totally and utterly disingenuous”.

Cllr Jane Hanna (Lib Dem) said she was the only councillor who “properly fought” for the convening of the committee, but wanted it to end, saying that councillors have come together with residents to scrutinise maternity services and that she had sent letters to the health trust CEO.

She said, despite the Horton HOSC not coming together, she has made scrutiny happen.

Ms Hanna said: “It’s hard to get those scrutiny committees across large geographies actually working in practice.

“It’s hard to get timely scrutiny.

“We have to ensure that timely scrutiny is available for the residents of Banbury.”

Cllr Ian Middleton (Green) added: “I really am concerned about what message this sends.

“If we do abolish the Horton HOSC – I know it’s quite instrumental in the fight that was mentioned last in terms of covering maternity, the consultant maternity unit in Horton.

“We’re also seeing other structural issues with the Horton Hospital, and I think this position in serving such a specific area, in my view, does deserve at least its own, the principle of its own overview and scrutiny committee.”

At the end of the debate, there were nine votes for the removal of the committee, 38 against and 16 abstentions.

The Horton HOSC is set to remain in place.

News you can trust since 1838
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice